Primetime: A Darkly Absurd Take on To Catch a Predator

Date:

It’s 9 p.m. on a Wednesday. Are you aware of your children’s whereabouts?

If you are the dramatized version of To Catch a Predator host Chris Hansen, as played by Robert Pattinson in A24’s Primetime, you’re certain you do—at least, you’ve persuaded your network that you know where everyone else’s children are.

Hansen, while sipping a drink, explains to his fellow passenger on a flight: this is the very reason his show was approved. He informs his executives that kids aren’t wandering the streets or tumbling down wells; instead, they are isolated in their rooms. Outside, Hansen claims, stands a man on the porch, exposing himself. In movie-Hansen’s shockingly crude portrayal, which we won’t fully quote, he is ready to rush into that bedroom.

However, if viewers tune into To Catch a Predator tonight on NBC, Hansen promises to reveal how to prevent such situations.

WATCH | Primetime trailer:

The significance of the guidance he offers is clear to anyone familiar with the events of that 2004 series. The Dateline program featured Hansen emerging from closets and bedrooms to confront alleged child predators lured into traps by his team—leading to notorious failed prosecutions, dangerous imitators, and at least one fatality.

Yet, Primetime is far from a straightforward critique. The film, which navigates this tumultuous history, unfolds as a whirlwind of absurdity and eccentricity. It presents a chaotic, spiraling dark comedy. Its unsettling nature (produced by The Strange Thing About the Johnsons’ Ari Aster) makes the combination of casual humor with disturbing horror feel almost expected.

We witness Tony Revolori (Spider-Man: Homecoming) making exaggerated, absurd expressions at the camera alongside images of dismembered children’s bodies left in an unknown jungle. Pattinson’s Hansen is seen inexplicably spewing mouthwash into a sink while adopting a posture that resembles more of a menacing bird than a journalist.

Later, we observe this goose-like figure pursuing an actual monster, a representation of what is supposedly lurking outside societal norms. But as he continues his search for evil beyond himself and confronts it, we also gaze back into his own darkness.

Pattinson’s performance showcases his signature unembarrassed dedication to character: an apparent inability to feel shame that enables him to fully embrace accents, impersonations, and sheer absurdity.

In this instance, he embodies a campy, exaggerated version of Chris Hansen: one who drawls “Why don’t you take a seat” with a serious, gravelly tone that, in the hands of anyone else, would come off as laughable.

A man poses in front of a bathroom mirror

The bizarre, chaotic portrayal of Chris Hansen in Primetime conveys something new and peculiar about the To Catch a Predator host. (Elevation Pictures)

According to director Lance Oppenheim and writer Ajon Singh, all these exaggerated quirks aim to reveal a profound decay at the core of the real man. Since it draws inspiration from the searing article “Tonight on Dateline This Man Will Die,” which discusses a shocking outcome from one of his stings, Primetime does not portray Hansen’s Dateline series in a favorable light. The screenplay resonates with criticisms—and even legal judgments—against the subsequent “Creep Catcher” groups that would replicate To Catch a Predator‘s methods, offering clear and strong denunciations.

This emphasis likely explains why the actual Chris Hansen has not exactly embraced the project.

In fact, he claims to have purchased his own advertisements prior to the film’s release to assert that the narrative presented is entirely fictional. Much like the Church of Latter-day Saints did in the Playbill for The Book of Mormon, he directs audiences to his own body of work where he contends the authentic story resides.

The true-crime streaming service he has since established continues to produce content regarding sexual offenses. An unending stream of new shows follows the format of, and capitalize on the public’s unquenchable desire for, the public-shaming vigilantism of To Catch a Predator.

The critical perspective of Primetime‘s funhouse-mirror portrayal is evident. Rather than granting Predator‘s seemingly noble objectives any semblance of validation, Oppenheim’s goal is to deconstruct Hansen’s presumed self-interest while empathetically portraying his targets.

Throughout Hansen’s exchanges with a beleaguered producer (Merritt Wever), a visibly traumatized and exploited “decoy” actor used to lure these alleged offenders (Skyler Gisondo), and the compassionately depicted subjects themselves, the message of Primetime is unmistakable.

The frantic and self-absorbed Hansen does not operate Predator as if it were a noble mission, the film suggests. He does not coerce local law enforcement into circumventing search and seizure laws, awaken his barely school-aged sons in the middle of the night to witness his latest capture, or glare at NBC reporter Stone Phillips reporting on “real” news out of a sense of altruism.

In Primetime‘s perspective, his motivations are simply to achieve prime time status.

A man walks down a spiral staircase. To his left another man looks up at him.

Robert Pattinson, right, is seen with actor Tony Revolori in a scene from Primetime. (Elevation Pictures)

That alone is not sufficient. The notion that respectability was the first casualty on television is painfully apparent; it was not adequate to sustain the sci-fi critique of capitalism The Running Man last year, nor is it enough to support the Rupert Murdoch/Larry Lamb biopic Ink that screened at this year’s TIFF.

Additionally, it is insufficient to merely recognize the pervasive anxiety surrounding stranger danger that has influenced political campaigns and platforms over the last five decades. From the genuinely poignant, loosely inspired narrative of six-year-old Etan Patz’s disappearance in Without a Trace to the disturbingly exploitative child-trafficking film Sound of Freedom, the overwhelming fear surrounding children’s safety is already evident.

What Primetime delves into is more probing and unsettling. It raises a question not merely of self-deception, but about how a lack of compassion appears to be justified, even promoted, in dealing with Hansen’s targets.

This theme is echoed by the same airplane companion, who queries Hansen about whether he ever contemplates bypassing the justice system to simply “bleed” the men he apprehends.

Hansen ponders this suggestion, then states that perhaps what he is doing is worse. And then he smiles.

Popular

More like this
Related

New Wave of F1 Content Creators Reshaping Fan Experience

Enzo Ferrari famously remarked, "If you ask any child...

Deadly Flash Floods Claim Over 160 Lives in Nepal-Tibet Border Area

On Wednesday, devastating flash floods in a border region...

Serena Williams Teams Up with Alcaraz for U.S. Open Comeback

Serena Williams is set to join forces with Carlos...

Hayden Panettiere’s Death Ruled Accidental Over Fentanyl Overdose

The recent passing of Hayden Panettiere has been classified...